Grafton.
Project Barbara · Investment Process

The Investment Process

From a broker pack to a decision — and on to completion · 7 June 2026

How we take an opportunity from a broker pack arriving in the inbox to a decision to proceed or abort. The operating procedure that sits between Investment Strategy (why we buy, how we price) and Diligence → Onboarding (what happens once we commit).

1The governing principle — work follows conviction

We see far more opportunities than we will ever buy, so we spend effort in proportion to conviction. Most opportunities should die cheap, after a couple of hours' reading; a few earn the full underwrite. We never want a 14-tab model built for a deal we were never going to pursue — and we never want to pass on a good one because the work felt too heavy to start.

The process is a staircase. Each step produces one deliverable, costs more than the last, and only happens because we read the previous one and said "go." There are no pre-assigned lanes — an opportunity climbs as far as our conviction takes it, and parking or declining is a first-class outcome at every step.

Everything up to the offer runs on the broker pack and the public record only — we don't touch the live business data until our offer is accepted and diligence opens. Two companion documents bound this one:

2The spine — one living deal memo that matures

Every target gets one deal memo, and every memo is a LiveDoc (a target-<name> wiki page + branded HTML — never bare markdown). The memo carries a status and a version + date, and climbs three rungs as we choose to invest more work:

RungStatusWhat it isThe work behind it
1PreliminaryThe read from the pack + the public record (§3) — no spreadsheet. Identity, the book, lettings:sales mix, rough economics on headline figures, key-person read, the public-record scan, thesis-fit, a first verdict + priority.Read the pack; scan the public record; apply the thesis. ½–1 day.
2AnalysisPreliminary + the financial model. KPI scorecard, the reported→normalised profit bridge, revenue-per-employee, the three cases (Downside / Base / Upside). The honest multiple.Build the acquisition model; promote the memo. +1–3 days.
3Investment CaseAnalysis + our judgement baked in — the case we'd act on. Refined three cases, the Tier-1 professionalisation checklist + Tier-2 enhance-margin playbook, a clear recommendation tied to the floor test. (At this stage we also ready the offer package — §4.)Our feedback + model refinement. +1–2 days.

It is the same memo throughout — the status and version say how cooked it is. A Preliminary v2 has been refreshed on new information but not modelled; an Investment Case v1 is ready to act on. The 10-section memo format is owned by the deal-memo skill; the rungs just fill in more of it.

3The Preliminary stage — read the pack, scan the public record

The cheap, public work is done up front, before any modelling, because it is exactly what tells us whether an opportunity is worth the heavier analysis. Two sources, both public:

  1. Reviews — across Google, Trustpilot, allAgents, Facebook. Per platform: rating, count, recency; a blended score; the recurring themes (top praise / complaints — slow repairs, deposit disputes, communication); whether the owner replies; and the landlord-vs-tenant skew (landlord sentiment matters most for a fee book). A read on operational health the accounts can't give.
  2. Website — services and published fees (corroborates the pack), positioning and target market (prime vs volume), branding, portal/tech signals, the team page (corroborates the staff list and key people), and the branch & coverage footprint.
  3. Listings — Rightmove / Zoopla / OnTheMarket, lettings and sales, split by available · under offer / let agreed · recently let / sold. Counts, asking rents and prices (validates avg-rent and the sales-desk read), and the let-agreed / under-offer ratio as a live demand-and-velocity signal. Visible let stock is also a sanity check on the claimed managed book.
  4. Key individuals — the owners, directors and partners as people. Companies House (filing history, other and former directorships, disqualifications), LinkedIn and the web (background, tenure, age corroboration), any press or prior ventures. Surfaces who really runs the business, competing interests (other agencies, referral/mortgage entities — directly relevant to non-compete), and whether the operator we'd need to retain is credible and findable.

The scan is corroboration and signal, not ground truth. A managed book is mostly not advertised, so visible listings are a floor, never a count; reviews skew to complaints; respect each platform's terms. Where the scan contradicts the pack, that becomes a flagged item — never a silent assumption.

The scan's structured outputs are stored against the opportunity and feed the Preliminary memo's book-quality, market-position, ownership and risk sections — and the verdict that decides whether we climb to Analysis.

4The Investment-Case offer package — readied before we offer

The work of the Investment Case stage is not only to mature the memo to its final rung — it is to assemble the offer package: the three documents that make us ready to transact the moment we decide to proceed. They are kept separate and individually editable, because each is a substantial piece of work:

With the package ready, the proceed decision is simply: make the offer. The deal then moves Offer Made → Under Offer → Completion — and Under Offer is where Diligence → Onboarding runs: due diligence and the ingestion of the real portfolio as the kernel of the operating system are one continuous process during the offer period.

5The staircase — stages, deliverables, gates and skills

An opportunity carries one thing: its stage — its position in the funnel. Everything else — each memo rung, the model, the term sheet, the 90 day memo, the DD plan — is a deliverable linked to the opportunity: a separate, versioned, individually-editable document. The stage is the position; the deliverables are the evidence. Each stage has a skill that produces its deliverable, so we invoke exactly the increment we want ("run the analysis skill on Flatman") rather than an all-or-nothing triage.

#StageDeliverable(s) linked hereSkill(s)The gate (your call)
0Sourcedthe opportunity + broker contact(manual log)Request the pack
1Info Receiveddocument registeropportunity-intakePack readable → write Preliminary
2PreliminaryPreliminary memo + market scandeal-memo + market-scanInteresting? → Analysis · park · decline
3Analysisacquisition model; memo → Analysisacquisition-analysisLike it? → Investment Case · park · decline
4Investment Casememo → Investment Case + the offer package: Heads of Terms · DD Plan · 90 Day Memoinvestment-case · term-sheet · dd-plan · ninety-day-memoProceed? → make the offer · decline
5Offer Madethe Heads of Terms, submittedAccepted? → Under Offer
6Under Offer= diligence-onboarding — DD + ingest the real portfolio as the OS kernel(its own discipline)Complete · withdraw
7Completion
Passed (from any gate)a decline email — you review before it sendsdeclineSent → mark Passed

Stages 2–4 are the heart of this process — the evaluation staircase, run on the pack and public record, each rung a deliberate decision to spend more. Stage 4 assembles the offer package; deciding to proceed means making the offer (→ Offer Made). When the offer is accepted (Under Offer) we move into Diligence → Onboarding — diligence and data-ingestion as one process — through to Completion. The old monolithic opportunity-dd-triage is retired — or kept only as a convenience that chains the stage skills in order.

6The decline skill

When we abort at any gate, the decline skill drafts a courteous decline email to the broker or seller — referencing the opportunity, giving a real but diplomatic reason (off-thesis / sub-scale / price / timing), and keeping the door open where we'd want it. It is drafted for review and never sent without sign-off. On send, the opportunity moves to Passed and the reason is logged. Brokers talk to each other; a graceful, prompt no is part of being the buyer they bring the next deal to.

7The current pipeline

Where the five live opportunities sit today, and the single next decision each is waiting on. (None has had the §3 public-record scan yet — it's a new Preliminary input we can add to any of them.)

TargetReadMemo statusStageNext gate / action
Glenn Flegg (J300)🟢 PrimaryAnalysis+Investment CaseComplete the offer package — HoT drafted (hot-glenn-flegg); write the DD Plan + 90 Day Memo — then make the offer
Flatman (J298)🟢 Bolt-onAnalysisAnalysisLike it?Investment Case as a Glenn Flegg tuck-in (10-min walk, Burnham)
Houseshaw (J303)🟠 WatchAnalysis (over-built for a Watch)Preliminary (parked)Parked — already published; no further work unless price/process moves
Martindon🟠 WatchPreliminary (note only)PreliminaryPublish the Preliminary memo as a LiveDoc, then park
Hoopers🟠 WatchPreliminary (note only)PreliminaryPublish the Preliminary memo as a LiveDoc, then park

The outstanding work collapses to: complete Glenn Flegg's offer package and make the offer; promote Flatman to Investment Case; publish Martindon + Hoopers' preliminary memos and park them. No new spreadsheets for the lukewarm ones — they sit at Preliminary until they earn the next step.

8How the deal-room represents this

The deal-room app mirrors the model:

Built: the deliverable link-chips, the registry, and the staircase stages. To come: stored market-scan signals and the thesis-fit league-table sort.

9The staircase at a glance

                 ── pack + public record only ──
Sourced         → opportunity + broker contact
Info Received   → document register
Preliminary     → memo (PRELIMINARY) + market scan ..... interesting? → up / park / decline
                  ├─ pack        → qualitative read + headline economics
                  └─ public rec. → reviews · website · listings · key individuals
Analysis        → financial model; memo → ANALYSIS ..... like it?     → up / park / decline
Investment Case → memo → INVESTMENT CASE
                  + offer package: Heads of Terms · DD Plan · 90 Day Memo ... PROCEED? → make the offer / decline
──────────────────────────── (offer made) ────────────────────────────
Offer Made      → Heads of Terms submitted ............. accepted?
Under Offer     → = diligence-onboarding: DD + ingest the REAL portfolio
                  as the KERNEL of the operating system
Completion      → done
                                          ↘  (abort any gate) → decline → Passed